Weird Science

The Double Cluster in Perseus, the Heart Nebula, the Soul Nebula, and nearby star clusters

Polish ver­sion is here

Per­seus is one of the lar­ger con­stel­la­tions of the nor­thern sky, ran­king 24th in size among those reco­gni­zed today. It is part of the autumn con­stel­la­tions group and is most pro­mi­nen­tly visi­ble from mid-lati­tude regions such as Poland during autumn. The num­ber of stars visi­ble to the naked eye in this con­stel­la­tion is esti­ma­ted to be aro­und 90. Per­seus is also one of the 48 con­stel­la­tions descri­bed by Pto­lemy.

Accor­ding to ancient Greek mytho­logy, Per­seus was the son of Zeus and Danaë, and one of the gre­a­test heroes in Greek lore.

The king of Argos, Acri­sius, had been told by an oracle that he would die at the hands of his own grand­son. After Per­seus was born, the king had his dau­gh­ter Danaë and her child sea­led inside a chest and cast into the sea, inten­ding to pre­vent the pro­phecy from coming true. Howe­ver, Zeus ensu­red the chest washed ashore on the island of Seri­phos, where Dik­tys, bro­ther of King Poly­dec­tes, took them in. As Per­seus grew up, Poly­dec­tes sent him on a see­min­gly hope­less quest for the head of the fear­some Medusa (the youn­gest of the Gor­gons, whose sisters were Stheno and Eury­ale), whose gaze tur­ned any­one who loo­ked at her into stone. Thanks to the gods, Per­seus rece­i­ved use­ful gift­s—inc­lu­ding win­ged san­dals, a magic pouch, and the Hel­met of Invi­si­bi­lity from the nym­phs, a steel sic­kle from Her­mes, and a shield from Athe­na­—and suc­ce­e­ded in behe­a­ding Medusa. From the blood of this mon­ster sprang the famous win­ged horse Pega­sus, later rid­den by Bel­le­ro­phon. On his way back thro­ugh Ethio­pia, Per­seus saved the beau­ti­ful prin­cess Andro­meda from a sea mon­ster cal­led Cetus (the Whale). He then took her to Seri­phos as his bride. Upon retur­ning to the island, he disco­ve­red Poly­dec­tes’s tre­a­chery and used Medusa’s head to turn the entire court, inc­lu­ding the king, to stone. Per­seus then tra­ve­led with his wife and mother back to his home­town of Argos. During some ath­le­tic games, an acci­den­tal throw of a discus struck his grand­fa­ther’s head, ful­fil­ling the pro­phecy. After his death, Per­seus was pla­ced among the stars by the gods, along­side Andro­meda, her parents Cas­sio­peia and Cepheus, as well as Cetus and Pega­sus.

Within the boun­da­ries of the con­stel­la­tion Per­seus lie many intri­gu­ing deep-sky objects. I will discuss seve­ral of them in the course of the fol­lo­wing obse­rva­tions.

Obse­rva­tions

Sep­tem­ber 15, 2020, aro­und 11:30 PM – Jaworzno (Poland)
sub­ur­ban con­di­tions, high level of light pol­lu­tion

That night, the sky was occa­sio­nally a bit hazy, and at times there were some pas­sing clo­uds. Unde­ter­red, I went out to my gar­den to enjoy the view of the night sky. After set­ting up my equ­ip­ment, I noti­ced that the region of Per­seus appe­a­red to be free of clo­uds, haze, or any atmo­sphe­ric distur­ban­ces that could ham­per obse­rva­tions. Con­se­qu­en­tly, I mana­ged to gather eno­ugh data, which resul­ted in Photo 1.

The pho­to­graph covers the area of the sky near the boun­dary between Per­seus and Cas­sio­peia (as con­fir­med by the pre­sence of both Eta (η Per­sei), known as Miram, and Epsi­lon (ε Cas­sio­pe­iae, or Segina), where the hero’s hand hol­ding a sword was tra­di­tio­nally ima­gi­ned. So many inte­re­sting objects are visi­ble here that I can har­dly decide which one to start with.

NGC 663 (Cal­d­well 10) is a young open clu­ster for­mally loca­ted within the boun­da­ries of Cas­sio­peia. It was disco­ve­red by Wil­liam Her­schel on Novem­ber 3, 1787, and lies about 8,000 light-years from the Sun. It con­ta­ins aro­und 400 stars, rou­ghly 20–25 mil­lion years old. The clu­ster inc­lu­des at least five so-cal­led blue strag­glers, which appear signi­fi­can­tly hot­ter and bluer than other stars of simi­lar bri­ght­ness, making them seem much youn­ger.

Ano­ther com­pa­ra­ble object is NGC 1027, which is clo­se­r—just over 3,000 light-years away. It, too, was disco­ve­red by Her­schel. NGC 1027 is an open clu­ster in Cas­sio­peia, found in 1787. It sits between two emis­sion nebu­lae but is not phy­si­cally asso­cia­ted with them. The clu­ster’s bri­gh­test star has a magni­tude of about 9.3m.

A simi­larly intri­gu­ing object is the open clu­ster Stock 2. Its stars are spread out rather loo­sely, and the clu­ster’s angu­lar dimen­sions can reach up to 1°, about twice the size of the full Moon. The clu­ster is about 1,050 light-years away. Its ove­rall bri­ght­ness is usu­ally peg­ged at aro­und 4.4m, but with a good pair of bino­cu­lars (10×50 will do, tho­ugh 15×70 is bet­ter), one can discern about 20 stars of ~8m. Many obse­rvers find that this clu­ster, some­ti­mes dub­bed the Muscle Man or the Bal­le­rina clu­ster, resem­bles a sty­li­zed human figure (shown sche­ma­ti­cally in Photo 2).

This col­lec­tion is rela­ti­vely under­stu­died. The clu­ster’s age is esti­ma­ted at 450 ± 150 mil­lion years, and the ave­rage mass of its stars is aro­und 2.8 M.

A deli­ght­ful sur­prise was that, in addi­tion to star clu­sters, the sim­ple pho­to­gra­phic tech­ni­que I used also cap­tu­red as many as three nebu­lar objects: the Heart Nebula, the Fish Head Nebula, and the Soul Nebula.

The Heart Nebula (IC 1805) is both an H II region and an emis­sion nebula loca­ted in the Per­seus Arm (one of the spi­ral arms of our Galaxy). This nebula, which resem­bles the human heart sym­bol (Photo 3), lies about 7,500 light-years from Earth and spans rou­ghly 200 light-years.

Its vivid red light is pri­ma­rily emit­ted by hydro­gen (H2), the most abun­dant ele­ment in the Uni­verse. At the Heart Nebula’s cen­ter is the open clu­ster Melotte 15—a very young assem­bly of stars merely 1.5 mil­lion years old. This clu­ster con­ta­ins a few bri­ght OB-type stars with mas­ses up to 50 times that of the Sun, along with nume­rous fain­ter stars with only a frac­tion of the Sun’s mass.

Right next to the Heart Nebula lies the Fish Head Nebula (IC 179), ano­ther emis­sion nebula. It is part of a com­plex star-for­ming region situ­a­ted along the edge of a large mole­cu­lar cloud in the Per­seus Arm of the Milky Way.

The Soul Nebula (IC 1848) is in many ways simi­lar to the Heart Nebu­la­—like it, this nebula is an H II region and an emis­sion nebula. Howe­ver, it is sli­gh­tly clo­ser to us, at aro­und 6,000 light-years away. The desi­gna­tion IC 1848 also refers to the asso­cia­ted open clu­ster disco­ve­red by Edward Bar­nard in the late 1890s, which illu­mi­na­tes the nebula and has an appro­xi­mate magni­tude of 6.5m.

The Dou­ble Clu­ster in Per­seus occu­pies the 14th posi­tion (Cal­d­well 14) in the cata­log com­pi­led by the renow­ned ama­teur astro­no­mer and science com­mu­ni­ca­tor Alfred Patrick Cal­d­well-Moore. It is also known as the Sword Han­dle or h+χ Per­sei.

The Dou­ble Clu­ster com­pri­ses two open clu­sters: NGC 869 and NGC 884.

The Dou­ble Clu­ster in Per­seus was first recor­ded by the Greek astro­no­mer Hip­par­chus, but we can be cer­tain it was obse­rved much ear­lier, since it is easily visi­ble to the una­i­ded eye under sui­ta­ble con­di­tions.

Both clu­sters lie over 7,000 light-years from Earth but are loca­ted very close to each othe­r—only a few hun­dred light-years apart. Ano­ther simi­la­rity is their appro­xi­mate age, which can be dedu­ced from the pro­per­ties of their mem­ber stars. They are rela­ti­vely young gro­up­s—NGC 869 is rou­ghly 5.6 mil­lion years old, and NGC 884 about 3.2 mil­lion years old. Both clu­sters are moving toward Earth at a speed of just over 20 km/s.

Each clu­ster occu­pies an angu­lar size cor­re­spon­ding to the appa­rent dia­me­ter of the full Moon. NGC 869 is bri­gh­ter, more com­pact, and con­ta­ins more stars than NGC 884. Most stars in these clu­sters are blue-white, but in and near NGC 884, there are seve­ral red giants. Thro­ugh bino­cu­lars, one can see a curved tail of stars run­ning toward the pre­vio­u­sly men­tio­ned clu­ster Stock 2.

The Dou­ble Clu­ster in Per­seus has been fea­tu­red in lite­ra­ture. In the novels of the Peo­ple as Gods (Люди как боги) cycle by Soviet wri­ter Ser­gey Sne­gov, this region was the home of the male­vo­lent Demiur­ges who thre­a­te­ned huma­nity.

Pho­tos 1, 2, 3 Para­me­ters:

  • Total expo­sure time: 60 minu­tes (stack of 30 RAW fra­mes at 120s each, using an appro­priate num­ber of dark, bias, and flat fra­mes)
  • Canon EOS 60D
  • ISO: 3200
  • Lens: zoom type (used at fmax = 250mm)
  • A fil­ter was used to reduce the effects of arti­fi­cial light pol­lu­tion and atmo­sphe­ric glow
  • Mount: equ­a­to­rial mount with trac­king, ali­gned using the drift method and con­trol­led by a custom-built sys­tem.

Photo 4 Para­me­ters:

  • Total expo­sure time: 20 minu­tes (stack of 10 RAW fra­mes at 120s each, using an appro­priate num­ber of dark, bias, and flat fra­mes)
  • Canon EOS 60D
  • ISO: 2500
  • Mak­su­tov-Cas­se­grain tele­scope (100/1400), prime focus expo­sure
  • A fil­ter was used to reduce the effects of arti­fi­cial light pol­lu­tion and atmo­sphe­ric glow
  • Mount: equ­a­to­rial mount with trac­king, ali­gned using the drift method and con­trol­led by a custom-built sys­tem

Marek Ples

Aa